
The Barking Dog's current location in Bethesda draws a healthy night-life crowd many hope to see in its upcoming College Park spot.
The Thirsty Turtle’s former location won’t be vacant for much longer. The Barking Dog, a Bethesda-based establishment, is on track to be the latest bar in the infamous venue.
When students caught wind of the possible contender for the new Route 1 watering hole, news spread across the campus like wildfire. And now that the Prince George’s County Board of License Commissioners approved owner John McManus’s petition for a liquor license, students can expect a new dog in the house by this fall.
Many students have responded with reserved excitement, but that eagerness for another Route 1 destination is somewhat overshadowed by skepticism that it could truly fill Turtle’s void.
The Barking Dog is a far cry from Turtle, students familiar with its other location in Bethesda said. Patrons shouldn’t expect the same level of debauchery as from a night on Turtle’s dizzying dance floor. Other bars have come and gone in that same spot, ousted by liquor inspectors, but this dog appears to be of a different species.
McManus has told both the liquor board and the College Park City Council that he’s never been cited for alcohol or noise violations and plans to maintain that clean record in College Park, adding he’ll try to stick around longer than Turtle proved capable of doing.
And it seems that the council intends to put as many measures in place as it can to ensure he follows through: The business must maintain a 50-50 food-alcohol ratio and bouncers must hold down the fort during peak hours using (gasp) ID scanners to keep out the high-school kids.
And then there’s the pitchers.
While students flocked to Turtle every Tuesday for the beloved $2-pitcher night, The Barking Dog will charge a minimum of $9 for the oversized mugs.
“Pitcher night was a staple here. People would be looking forward to that even from the weekend,” said junior mathematics major Andrew Triola. “It’s not gonna be like Tuesdays at Turtle, where it’s just packed by like 8 p.m.”
“I still think people will still come out to Pitcher Night because the other two bars have been so packed,” added Cheyenne Braga, a sophomore marketing major who has worked at both Turtle and The Barking Dog. “I just don’t think it’ll be as big a night because Turtle was so cheap and easier for college students.”
And in a college town, students said the price of drinks and frequency of specials determines a bar’s success more than any other factors.
“As long as there is a $2 beer special, the place will be packed,” said Patrick Moxley, a senior mechanical engineering major. “Once beers get to the $3 mark, that’s where most people start to shy away.”
Though The Barking Dog may never be the new freshman hang-out, several upperclassmen said they are warming to the idea of a more exclusive — read: legal — bar.
“I think a bar that is really strict with IDs is good,” Moxley said. “To get away from all the underclassmen is nice. Maybe if they didn’t have a $5 cover and charged $3 or $4 for a beer that would be OK.”
Students will have to wait and see if McManus honors his pledges to operate a law-abiding, responsible restaurant and bar. Many said they hope he doesn’t.
Others said it’s about time for College Park to clean up its image. Either way, if all goes according to plan, The Barking Dog could become the next Route 1 mainstay.
But a key question lingers: How long will there be a market for a classier bar that won’t admit underage patrons but boasts a 900-person capacity?
“It was kinda nice to have a shitty place you could go where you didn’t have to pay a lot of money,” Triola said. “I’m 21 now, so now that we don’t have to worry about getting in or not, it’s nice to go to a nicer place sometimes and order good drinks. But it’s definitely good to have the best of both worlds.”
The establishment will inevitably enjoy an initial wave of intensely high traffic as bar-hoppers pounce on the opportunity for a change of scenery. Ultimately, though, students will have to wait and see if the newcomer lives up to the hype or if its bark is bigger than its bite.
— Alissa Gulin